Whereas going via bins of outdated shopper recordsdata, a Reddit person discovered a gooey treasure.
Redditor u/mrpeabodyscoaltrain, who works as an legal professional in Tennessee and most popular to stay nameless, shared a photograph of an old recipe he discovered whereas destroying closed recordsdata in his workplace, and the Reddit baking community went loopy for it.
Written in cursive handwriting on a yellowing piece of lined paper, the recipe for “Gory Cake” features a stick of margarine, chopped pecans and an fascinating topping of cream cheese, eggs and a whole 16-ounce field of powdered sugar.
However u/mrpeabodyscoaltrain says after performing some analysis, he thinks the identify of the recipe could also be written incorrectly.
“I did a bit of little bit of analysis, and apparently that is ‘Gooey Cake,'” he informed TODAY Food. “It’s a Missouri recipe based mostly on all the things I’ve learn. I am unsure who wrote down the recipe, it was simply stuffed in a field.”
In accordance with Grandbaby Cakes founder Jocelyn Delk Adams, who has a recipe for “Ooey Gooey Butter Cake” on this very website, this cake was invented decades ago, in St. Louis — not the South, as many have come to consider.
Courtesy Jocelyn Delk Adams
Whereas he hasn’t made the cake but himself, u/mrpeabodyscoaltrain says what stood out to him most was the cream cheese topping.
“What initially caught my eye about this recipe was baking the cream cheese on high of the cake,” he stated. “I believed that was a bit of odd.”
I, too, was intrigued by the baked layer of cream cheese, to not point out utilizing 1 / 4 cup of margarine and no precise liquids within the recipe. So, I attempted the recipe out for myself.
The cake, which the recipe says ought to be baked in a 9-by-13-inch baking pan, has two layers. The primary, product of yellow cake combine, margarine, an egg and chopped pecans, was extremely sticky. It was a problem to comply with the recipe’s directions to “pat into backside of pan,” however because of some cooking spray and a silicone spatula, I received it taken care of.
“This should be why it is referred to as ‘gooey cake,'” I believed to myself.
Then got here the second layer: cream cheese, eggs and powered sugar. The recipe says to combine the elements and layer them on high of the batter, however once more, the combination was so sticky, it required a number of focus.
“This should be why it is referred to as ‘gooey cake,'” I believed to myself, once more.
After cleansing my sticky fingers, it was time to pop my Gory Cake into the oven. I adopted the recipe, baking it for 50 minutes at 350 F.
When the cake got here out of the oven, the very first thing I observed was the golden brown crispness of the cream cheese topping. It was stunning and I could not wait to chop into my creation.
The underside layer of margarine, cake and pecans was gentle, heat, buttery heaven. It tasted just like the scent my residence was stuffed with whereas baking it: like heat caramel popcorn or heat toffee.
And sure, the within of the cake is gooey.
And sure, once more, I believed, “This should be why it is referred to as ‘gooey cake.'”
Gory or gooey, the cake was scrumptious. It is a distinctive option to make use of a boxed cake combine, and, whereas I am unsure it might be part of my go-to dessert recipe repertoire — like Nana’s Devils Food cake — it was a enjoyable, nostalgic factor to bake.
It is that nostalgia that u/mrpeabodyscoaltrain says led him to share the outdated recipe within the first place.
“Older recipes on the whole are fascinating as a result of they allow us to see into how individuals of the previous ate,” he stated. “Previous household recipes are particularly fascinating as a result of they present the traditions of various households.”